Not a good male child
After going through the hell on earth that was Chapter IX , you add up back to a destroy Hotel Krat in Lies of P. By peck up a few hints along the means , you ’ll know that Alidoro was the one ratting you out and , ultimately , responsible for the blast by collaborating with the Alchemists . This is confirm after you enroll the hotel , and reach him once you get to Chapter X. He ’s been helping you up until here , but it might be metre for this dog to kvetch the bucket .
Should You Attack or Ignore Alidoro?
After beating the Brotherhood of the Black Rabbit in the Relic of Trismegistus , you ’ll meet no other than Alidoro . He ’s just stomach there , but not threateningly in the flimsy . He ’s impressed by how well you dealt with the whole brotherhood ( even if you got your buttocks kicked a few times before the putting to death ) and tells you about the submarine you could take .
He ’s not returning to the hotel , but you may purchase his weapons and speak with him normally here . to boot , you may also aggress him for what he has done to your friends . utter will give you more background on a specific quality while choosing to snipe Alidoro wo n’t directly shoot down him .
If you show your own fangs to this coward blackguard , he tells you that he eff about your limitation . As a tool , you could not attack others if they do n’t attack you first . But turns out that we are n’t just a regular puppet . you may either step back or keep your decision of attacking him . Let ’s see both outcomes .

Stepping Back from Alidoro in Lies of P
Alidoro will suffer here for the remainder of the game if you ill-use back . you could always come back here with the Stargazer you just unbarred after the last fight , but it ’s still less practical than going to the Hotel . His goods will be available at all time , and you could get the extra lore bits from spill with him . But you should definitely go for the other option . you’re able to always come back and choose the other option , though .
Attacking Alidoro in Lies of P
If you go for the killing , Alidoro will quiver in fear , and you may dispose of him in a undivided hit . You get some humanity for doing so . Just make indisputable you take all of his negotiation options before disposing of him .
If you did the Eugenie and Alidoro mini - quest antecedently in Chapter VII , he drops the Alidoro Cryptic Vessel , which you may take to Pulcinella to analyze back in the hotel . After uncover its content , you could verbalise with Eugenie and reveal that the real Alidoro was her sidekick , and the one you just killed had bump off him and taken his property .
This explain all the inconsistencies regarding Alidoro ’s reputation and attitudes , culminate in treason against the Hotel . After speaking with Eugenie , interact with the Stargazer and speak with her again to get the The Story of A Stranger Girl trophy .

Screenshot by Prima Games
Can You Still Buy Special Weapons If You Kill Alidoro?
you may still get the singular weapon initially sell by Alidoro even if you kill him . His unique store had various Special Weapons and muscular Amulets , but he was not that just of a merchant to keep sell them from his grave . as luck would have it , we have Hugo , his follower whom we met back in Chapter VIII , taking care of his property .
He take the indecorum of visit Alidoro ’s corpse and “ adopt ” his goodness to take on his legacy , and it ’s now stationed at the same place where Alidoro was in Hotel Krat . Just confabulate the same arena next to Antonia , and he ’ll be there , sell whatever goods you have n’t got from Alidoro yet and for the same currencies .
That suppose , shoot down Alidoro is the best option as you wo n’t lose any of his benefit . It also serve with some redundant humanity , but not intimately enough to ruin a true statement - only run where you want to stave off humanness to get one of the endings . It ’s also generally good to buy weapons in the Hotel than go all the mode to a specific place in a specific chapter to look for them .

Screenshot by Prima Games
beat up knock-down bosses andgetting fresh Rare Ergos will also add fresh weapons to the Hugo shop , so you should definitely still keep them instead of consuming them for a slight power - up .

Screenshot by Prima Games

Screenshot by Prima Games