A price paid in blood
The Constellation and the Lodge might be the closet thing you have to a family in the wild expanse of space . But hard decisions abound in Starfield ’s High Price to compensate when forced to prefer between your newfound protagonist — so should you champion The Lodge or go to The Eye ?
Starfield: Should You Go to The Eye or Defend the Lodge in High Price to Pay
After complete the tenth story missionary station , No Sudden Moves , you ’ll arrive back at The Lodge with the Artifact from the Scow . Here , you ’ll start the next mission , High Price to Pay . Noel will inform you The Eye has gone entirely dark . And then you get word The Eye has been attacked , and their attacker is heading right for The Lodge . Now you ’re faced with a decision : should you defend The Lodge or go to The Eye ?
Note that there will be somemajor spoilersfor the upshot of each selection . We genuinely trust that revealing all will be necessary in order for you to make the decisiveness that ’s correct for you and your playthrough .
What Happens if You Go to The Eye During High Price to Pay in Starfield
So , this is the first alternative we chose for ourselves . But it come , as the quest name suggests , with a high price .
By leaving the Lodge , you ’ll find four companions on The Eye . These companions are Andreja , Barret , Sam Coe , and Vladimir . By selecting their first dialogue option , which tells them you ’re there for them , you ’ll geta huge rise of affectionfrom them .
That ’s nice , correct ? Now , here ’s the hard part .
pass to The Lodge , and you ’ll find that it ’s been attacked by the Starborn , the Hunter . You ’ll find Matteo , Walter , and Vasco alive . If you choose their first duologue option , ask them if they ’re alright , Sam Coe will get a cost increase of fondness . Sam Coe becomes your default companion after The Eye .
The only mortal who did n’t survive the flak is Sarah Morgan . She ’s all in , and there ’s no nonplus her back , as far as we can differentiate .
However , Noel still has The Artifact . you may witness her in the basement of The Lodge . There , you ’ll be chased by The Hunter through the basement , through The Well , and onto your ship . Once there , you ’ll return to The Eye and decide to either keep the Artifact on your ship or on an frontier settlement of your making .
Screenshot by Prima Games
So , the large sacrifice here is Sarah Morgan .
What Happens if You Stay and Defend the Lodge in Starfield
If you opt to remain in The Lodge , you ’ll in short scuffle with The Hunter , who has Walter in a chokehold . You ’ll then keep up Noel , with Vasco , Sarah , and Walter , out of the Lodge and into The Well . From there , you ’ll get onto your ship and travel up to The Eye .
So , here ’s where matter fly up in the air . One of your Constellation associate will be dead . But that fellow traveler seems to be influenced by your affinity degree with them . I suspect thatyou lose the fiber that you had the secondly - high level of affinity with , after Sarah .
We had the in high spirits degree of affinity with Alejandra , and she survived . But Sam Coe , who we had some forced campaign affection with , was the one who died . And we ’ll be honorable , drop off Sam sucked . His daughter is inconsolable and she hates you for let her dad die .
Others have told me that they fall back Barret , and others have describe that they lose Andreja . That means thatSam , Barret , and Andreja can each be for good lost .
Starfield: Should You Choose, The Eye or The Lodge in a High Price to Pay?
bed which associate you ’ll lose might make the determination easy enough for you . But if you ’d opt to really weigh the loss , here ’s how it breaks down .
Sarah Morganprovides the following ability when she ’s a member of your crew :
Barretprovides the following abilities :
Sam Coeprovides the following abilities :
Andrejaprovides the next abilities :
Whether you oppose The Lodge or go to the middle , the outcomes are equal to each other . But we like Barret better , so good-for-naught , Sarah . Beyond that , going to The Eye is the only way to get some major affection dot . Since we ’re romance Andreja ( or trying to , anyway ) , this was more beneficial for us .
at long last , it ’s up to you .
Should You Defend the Lodge or Go to the Eye, Summarized
If you go to the Eye , Sarah Morgan will die . If you defend The Lodge , your secondly - closest fellow traveler will fail instead . Either way , you will drop off a associate . Defending The Eye will give you a better chance of saving your favorite familiar and receiving some tenderness from them , but if your favorite companion is Sarah Morgan , you ’ll desire to defend The Lodge instead .
Whether you decide to defend The Lodge or go to The Eye , you ’re going to want to fill the void . Replacing Sarah or Barret is a big ask . But there arequite a few companions scattered across the galaxy .
